Written and created by Matthew Pejkovic

Contact: mattsm@mattsmoviereviews.net

Logo created by Colony Graphic Design

 
AWFUL
POOR
GOOD
GREAT
EXCELLENT
*
**
***
****
*****
 
 
2006
MAN OF THE YEAR

STARRING:ROBIN WILLIAMS,LAURA LINNEY,CHRISTOPHER WALKEN,LEWIS BLACK,JEFF GOLDBLUM,DAVID ALPAY,DOUG MURRAY

WRITTEN BY BARRY LEVINSON

PRODUCED BY DAVID ROBINSON & JAMES G. ROBINSON

DIRECTED BY BARRY LEVINSON

GENRE:COMEDY/THRILLER/ROMANCE

RATED:AUSTRALIA:MA/UK:N/A/USA:PG-13

RUNNING TIME:115 MIN

In their first film since the 1992 flop Toys, writer/director Barry Levinson and Robin Williams re-unite for Man of the Year. Williams plays Tom Dobbs, a political comedian ala Jon Stewart, who announces his candidacy for the President for the United States after his millions of fans urge him to take on the top job. Hitting the road with his manager Jack Menken (Christopher Walken) and their entourage, Dobbs begins his campaign boring the audiences who only want to hear his humorous antidotes on the political system, while he only wants to talk about the issues. Finally hitting his stride when he lets loose on his fellow candidates during the presidential debate, Dobbs surprises the world (and himself) when he unexpectedly wins the election. Meanwhile, Eleanor Green (Laura Linney) an employee for Delacroy Computers - a company which has provided the country with a new, computerized state of the art voting system - has found a glitch within the new system which incorrectly announced the winner of the presidential election. Afraid she will go to the press, her employers set up Eleanor as a drug crazed loon who lacks any credibility. Convinced that the truth must come out, Eleanor travels to Washington to let Dobbs know the election was a fraud, the two developing a relationship in the process.
Considering its cast, its filmmaker and its promising plot, it is a disappointment to say that Man of the Year is a bumbling, boring and underwhelming film. An uneasy mix of political satire and thriller, the film never hits its stride, with whatever potential it had held down by Levinson's uneven screenplay and the insipid performances of Williams and Linney. As a comedy it is not funny, as a thriller it is undone by its comedic elements, and its love story is an annoying, ridiculous distraction.
With his best performances these days coming from his work in drama's and thrillers, Williams proves that he is played out as a comedic actor. He has re-hashed the same ol' jokes over and over again (I have heard his intelligence design bit at least half a dozen times) and his arm flailing, speed ball theatrics have grown tiresome. It seems that Williams is channelling controversial comedian Bill Maher - a bad move considering Maher is neither funny nor bright - and maybe this explains his poor performance. Laura Linney - an actress who I am a big fan of - gives her worst performance to date. Whether it was the screenplay or Levinson's direction, this was the first time I cringed watching a performance from Linney, and there is nothing worse than watching one of your favourite actors struggling on screen.
Levinson does bring up a few important points, especially in regards to the accountability of America's elected leaders to the people they serve, and not to the companies and industries who fund their campaigns. But an important message I got from this movie is that guys like Stewart, Maher and Lewis Black (who coincidently co-stars), would not stand a chance standing in the place of the people they ridicule because it will be too hard, too big and too much of a job for them to handle.
The very idea of a comedian becoming the President of the United States is both a liberating and scary thought, and unfortunately does not make much of a movie. If you want great political satire, I would recommend Warren Beatty's Bulworth or Levinson's Wag the Dog. Stay clear from this drivel.
**
 
 

 

Copyright © Matthew Pejkovic 2007-2008